Best Broadway Shows in September 2019

Most Popular Broadway Shows
Find best prices & best seats

Best Broadway shows in New York City – September 2019 will be dazzling and star-studded. Summer is winding down and the colder months are coming, so we all need something to lift our spirits. Really, what better way to cheer up than a Broadway show? The leaves outside are turning brown but everything is still colorful on the Broadway stage! There’s no better way to bring some sunniness back into your life than seeing Broadway shows in September 2019. These productions are a great way to ease yourself into the wintery months ahead. – Guide to Most Popular & Upcoming shows in Broadway. Compare Prices & Find Tickets Best Prices & Best Seats.

Popular Broadway Shows in September – Reviews

Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812

The Great Comet is closing in September after a spectacular Broadway run. Certainly, the show will continue to be one of the best musical Broadway shows in September. The show is based on Tolstoy’s War and Peace but it’s not stuffy or overly intellectual like you might imagine. Instead, it is a gripping and lovable musical full of marvellous vocals and stellar acting. It tells the fraught story of Natasha who gets involved with someone new while her lover fights in the war. His friend suspiciously keeps an eye on the relationship as it develops. Josh Groban co-stars, so it’s also a great option for audiences angling to see a celebrity on Broadway.


Waitress is an endearing musical based on the 2007 film of the same name. With a sweet story, great acting, and music by successful pop songstress Sara Bareilles, it’s a real all-rounder. The show follows Jenna, a charming but downtrodden Southern waitress who unexpectedly becomes pregnant. She tries to hide the pregnancy from her useless partner, Earl, while she figures out what to do. When a new face arrives on the scene, it seems like there may be redemption for the lovely lead. With a delightful supporting cast and winning main character, Waitress is a genuinely charming musical production. Waitress is an engaging addition to Broadway shoes in September 2017 and one that shouldn’t be missed.


Aladdin is a roguish street urchin who is always getting into trouble. Meanwhile, Princess Jasmine is an adventurous soul whose father wants to marry her off to another royal. What happens when the two meet? Well, they create one of the sweetest and most energetic Broadways shows in September 2018! There’s a genie in a bottle, a transformative wish, and an evil enemy to boot. The musical is a classic underdog story that integrates love and comedy to great effect. While Aladdin is a great musical for kids, it will also keep adults entertained with funny quips and stunning visuals. Fans of the animated film will particularly love this excellent transition to the Broadway stage.


Everyone loves Hamilton and the show continues as one of the best Broadway shows in September. It’s a rap and hip hop musical that brings the story of Founding Father Alexander Hamilton to life. Hamilton came to New York after an early life in the Caribbean and found plenty of drama in the US. From his political passion to the intense rivalry he had with Aaron Burr, Hamilton’s life was action-packed. Lin-Manuel Miranda’s musical lets the story take hold of Broadway theaters to fantastic effect. Of all the Broadway shows in September 2017, Hamilton promises to be one of the most memorable. Everyone, from lifelong Broadway fans to theater first timers, will find something to love in this memorable production.

Dear Evan Hansen

Dear Evan Hansen is a touching portrayal of teenage angst and anxiety, neatly packaged in outstanding musical form. With a talented cast of actors and catchy songs, the production is a standout Broadway show in September. The story concerns a socially anxious high school student named Evan who is apprehensive about the school year ahead. His therapist suggests that he writes himself a letter and this is where the real story begins. When his letter and another family’s tragedy get mixed up together, Evan finally has the chance to achieve notoriety. What happens when he reaches out for a popularity he hasn’t exactly earned? Overall, the show is moving and funny, offering audiences expertly interspersed moments of sympathy and hilarity.

Beautiful: The Carole King Musical

Carole King is a song writing legend and her music has touched millions of lives. Beautiful: The Carole King Musical is a moving retelling of her life and career. The musical touches on all of King’s highs and lows, beginning when she is a pregnant teenager living in Brooklyn. Shortly after, King achieves her first big musical triumph and her career goes on to flourish. During the 1960s she achieved wider mainstream success and penned some iconic hits with her partner, Gerry Goffin. Later on, her solo album Tapestry was a breakout success, candidly charting a difficult time in King’s life. Beautiful recounts these tales with care and poignancy, cementing it as one of the best Broadway shows in September 2017. Music and Broadway fans alike will rejoice at this moving tribute to an amazing musician.

The Book of Mormon

Sensitive viewers may not enjoy The Book of Mormon, but the musical has been a mainstream success since its release. Penned by the creators of television’s salacious South Park, the show is a hilarious and irreverent Broadway romp. Two Mormon missionaries, one awkward and one overly self-confident, find themselves in Uganda with the aim of converting the locals. However, it soon becomes apparent that the local people have much more pressing issues to worry about. The Book of Mormon is packed with striking musical numbers and bawdy humor that will make you gasp. It’s not for the faint of heart but comedic theater fans should make sure to catch this side-splitting show.

Whatever type of theater you like, you’ll find something to love on Broadway this month. Don’t let the end of summer get you down – just get yourself to some Broadway shows in September 2018. After all, life is always vibrant and captivating when it’s onstage!

Monthly Schedule of Current Broadway Shows. Here is a rundown of current Broadway shows and their Monthly show times:

  1. Broadway Shows in January
  2. Broadway Shows in February
  3. Broadway Shows in March
  4. Broadway Shows in April
  5. Broadway Shows in May
  6. Broadway Shows in June
  7. Broadway Shows in July
  8. Broadway Shows in August
  9. Broadway Shows in September
  10. Broadway Shows in October
  11. Broadway Shows in November
  12. Broadway Shows in December

Broadway Shows in September 2019 – Find Tickets Best Prices

Hamilton Broadway Musical
Richard Rodgers Theatre, 226 West 46th St,New York,New York-10036
Starting on
Ending on
Hamilton Broadway Musical NYC 2019 Theater: Richard Rodgers Theatre Duration: 2 hours 55 minutes (1 intermission) Starring: Javier Muñoz, Brandon Victor Dixon, Lexi Lawson
Offer Price